Home › Forums › Trading System Mentor Course Community › Progress Journal › Sean’s Journal
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
May 12, 2023 at 1:16 pm #115596JulianCohenParticipant
A couple of things to consider, especially as this is ASX…
Are your price limits feasible to trade?
Are you compounding your results?
The second will relate to the first as if you are compounding then it will be almost impossible to trade the volume of any particular stock in 2022 with a 200 million account size. This can screw with your perceptions of the strategy.
Try switching to a shorter time frame, say 2010 to present and backtest non-compounded and see how the results come out. That might give you a more realistic outlook.
May 13, 2023 at 1:45 am #115597smurfki0808ParticipantYes, for sure Julian. Nick and I have talked about these issues. I don’t for a second think that it would be feasible to trade the compounding account to $200m.
Nick suggested to look at results over 5 year blocks, to see if similar performance measures come out and position sizes stay feasible.
Thanks for the feedback.
June 1, 2023 at 2:51 am #115420smurfki0808ParticipantMay 2023 – I continued developing a Mean Reversion system on the ASX, which has come together quite nicely. In back testing, it appears that there is an opportunity for an account size in my comfort zone. I have a few more checks to do with Craig next week regarding operational procedures, but the strategy looks like a worthy addition to my little stable of systems.
In the mean time, I have had a go at developing a Monthly rotation strategy using momentum ranking for the ASX100. Early days just yet, but at least I have the mechanics heading in the right direction. Now, I need to do some more development regarding regime filters, volatility filters and # positions to see if I can get close to Nick’s ASX MOMO performance.
Now in June, I am in my last month of the mentor program and I am working towards getting my processes in order, vis. IBKR, mechanics of multiple order placements, and so on.
Results for May
ASX WTT: -3.8%
ASX MOMO: 0.0%
ASX EMO: -2.9%
Managed Growth Fund: -0.9%Total -1.5% taking total drawdown to -22.8%
June 29, 2023 at 2:01 am #115421smurfki0808ParticipantA little update in late June 2023. I am at the end of my formal Mentor period with Nick and Craig. What I have learnt is a story for another post, but suffice to say at this stage, “you can teach anybody to design, code, test, and trade” a robust strategy. So for what you guys have taught me and exposed me to, I think my family and I will be forever grateful!
For me, the past 4 months has been non-stop learning, researching, analyzing, building, coding and thinking. All good things must come to an end as I return to my full-time job next week. So, over the last couple of weeks, I have worked on transitioning my mind from full-on systems development, to a place of implementation and execution. Slowly slowly, and softly softly. Setting up new brokerage accounts, planning movement of equity to allow implementation of my strategies etc. Dipping my toe in.
To that end, I can happily say that this morning I executed my first full circle mean reversion trade by closing out my first position! Does that feel good to someone who was rather reticent to go down the higher frequency trade route? You bet. For my position to close with a 8.8% win in just 3 days is just amazing. Was it just signal luck? Probably. Beginners luck? Sure. But, it certainly feels good. Especially the part that the signal came from a strategy that I developed (with help of course).
What did I learn by executing this first signal? There was a slight teething problem around the ranking, which I believe I sorted out, but it taught me another lesson about why in backtesting my strategy works. Did I get a complete fill? Yes, just $0.01 above the low of the entry day. Did my exit influence the opening today? Yes, slightly. My exit suppressed the opening auction price by ~1%, but it was a successful exit in the open. Could I have held the position to exit later in the day? Yes, but that would break my rules and I had no certainty that the price was going to keep rallying.
So with the completion of that trade, and the prospect of another 1000 like it, I feel like I have turned a corner. Will all my mean reversion trades be so profitable? Definitely not. But, my backtesting suggests a win rate of ~68%, so I should be confident to keep taking the signals. Today I have three entry signals in play, and another trade in play, and in the black for now. So, a positive start all round.
I will do another post of where I got to with my strategy development during the mentorship. Suffice to say, I wildly exceeded my objectives in what I achieved.
June 29, 2023 at 7:47 am #115644GlenPeakeParticipantWell Done Sean.
Nice Trade!!!!
Keep us updated on the progress!
June 29, 2023 at 8:32 am #115645StevenPolaMemberWay to go Sean.
Good Luck with the next 1000….June 29, 2023 at 10:00 am #115646smurfki0808ParticipantGlen Peake post=14088 userid=314 wrote:Well Done Sean.Nice Trade!!!!
Keep us updated on the progress!
Thanks Glen, my strategy has a bit of your wisdom buried inside it. Certainly a nice trade to kick off with. The backtest for June has so far returned 6.8% with 9 wins and 7 losses. Maybe I should have started earlier in the month?
June 29, 2023 at 10:01 am #115647smurfki0808ParticipantNice to have a positive start. Now for the next 1000….Cheers
June 29, 2023 at 9:33 pm #115648GlenPeakeParticipantSean Murphy post=14090 userid=5450 wrote:Thanks Glen, my strategy has a bit of your wisdom buried inside it. Certainly a nice trade to kick off with. The backtest for June has so far returned 6.8% with 9 wins and 7 losses. Maybe I should have started earlier in the month?Oh wow….. my wisdom…..?? Now you’re really going out on a limb and testing the waters!!! LOL
July 2, 2023 at 11:13 am #115422smurfki0808ParticipantA quick update for the month of June.
ASX WTT: -0.7%
ASX MOMO: 1.6%
ASX EMO: 0.3%
ASX MR#1:, First 2 test trades, 2 wins, for 5.6% profit.
Managed Growth Fund: -0.3%Total for month -0.1% taking total drawdown to -22.9%
For 2022-23, sideways all year, drawdown deepened from -21.1 to -22.9%
July 23, 2023 at 12:06 am #115662smurfki0808ParticipantCompeting trades from different strategies? Any words of wisdom?
For Monday, I have a BUY signal for SSM in my ASX WTT strategy, while The Chartist ASX Growth strategy has the same signal. I am not trading the latter. I suspect the equity tracking the Growth Strategy is somewhat larger than mine tracking my WTT, so interest at the open will be high.
So, I guess it might be prudent for me to be patient with my entry into SSM on the weekly strategy? How do others handle this type of scenario?
Cheers and thanks,
Sean
July 23, 2023 at 3:19 am #115681GlenPeakeParticipantHi Sean,
I ignore the outside ‘noise’ and place the trade and get the OPEN price.
Murphy’s Law (no pun intended) suggests that if you wait post open auction for price discovery to ‘settle’ down, the stock will run higher without you onboard and you’ll sit there saying to yourself “why didn’t I just get in on the OPEN”.
So follow your system and buy the open would be my approach.
FWIW:
If I get a ‘double up’ of buy orders for the same stock between e.g. my WTT and XSO monthly systems flag the same stock, I treat each signal separately and take the trade in both systems. No 2nd guessing, no sitting on the fence, just pull the trigger and be a robot and follow the system.Cheers
July 23, 2023 at 4:03 am #115682smurfki0808ParticipantGlen Peake post=14140 userid=314 wrote:I ignore the outside ‘noise’ and place the trade and get the OPEN price.Murphy’s Law (no pun intended) suggests that if you wait post open auction for price discovery to ‘settle’ down, the stock will run higher without you onboard and you’ll sit there saying to yourself “why didn’t I just get in on the OPEN”.
So follow your system and buy the open would be my approach.
FWIW:
If I get a ‘double up’ of buy orders for the same stock between e.g. my WTT and XSO monthly systems flag the same stock, I treat each signal separately and take the trade in both systems. No 2nd guessing, no sitting on the fence, just pull the trigger and be a robot and follow the system.Cheers
Hi Glen,
Yes, I accept your counsel. The rule is buy the open, so get on board. If I did not know the outside noise of the Growth Strategy signal existed, I would just get on board regardless.
Thanks for your thoughts, much appreciated.
By the by, my newly deployed ASX MR#1 system is up to 10 wins from 10 trades, averaging 3.5% profit per trade. Tomorrow, an exit (which will be the first loss) and a few more buy signals to enter. It will be interesting to see how it goes in this next week.
Cheers
S
August 1, 2023 at 10:29 am #115683smurfki0808ParticipantJuly saw me return to my day job, which frankly, seems a little less stimulating after sinking my teeth into the Mentor Program. So, July was a month of learning to balance a new bunch of competing demands, while bedding down my trading processes, reconciliations, and so on.
The good news is that I have completed one month of trading my ASX MR#1 strategy, following all signals and executing as per the rules. This was a real win for me, as before the Mentor Program, I thought running such a strategy would be beyond my capacity. The month revealed that with my code, my order sheet, and routine, I can process trades in about 10-15 minutes. I still check each signal on charts just to make sure nothing odd is happening, but it is well worth it. The month began really well, with 10 profitable trades in a row before a bit of pullback late in the month. In total, 14 completed trades, 11 wins, 3 losses, total return +3.3%. Two of the losing trades coming late in the month were tied up in earnings revisions, and trading halts, which didn’t end too well on resumption of trade. Why don’t those ones go in our favour?
In my ASX WTT, revisions also whacked a few positions, just after it went fully invested. Earnings expectations not being met apparently.
In looking for some further diversification in my trading strategies, I reexamined my ASX EMO, emerging momentum strategy. I built it to trade pretty much the same universe as my ASX WTT strategy, which at the time seemed a logical path for me to follow. However, I found that by expanding the price range of the universe, and reducing the # of positions, the metrics improved substantially.
So for me, a good month to have completed.
ASX WTT: -2.1%
ASX MOMO: 0.1%
ASX EMO: 0.5%
ASX MR#1: 3.3%
Managed Growth Fund: 2.5%Total for month 1.3% taking total drawdown to -21.7%
August 29, 2023 at 5:57 am #115423smurfki0808ParticipantA little project that has gnawed away at the back of my mind was to develop a monthly rotation strategy for the broader XAO minus the XTO section of the ASX. There are often some strong movers in there (up and down), so maybe it was worth my while.
Compared with my Monthly Rotation for the XTO, I quickly realised this section of the market is a little more challenging. The increased volatility appears to manifest in longer MaxWait times, and deeper MaxDD. I guess when the market decides “risk off”, this section gets hammered quicker than the XTO. To trade this part of the market, it looks like I would need to be comfortable with extended periods of drawdown, that turns around with a stampede. Hmmmm.
One potential solution may be to rotate twice a month, rather than once per month? Can anyone point me to AFL code that rotates every 10 days, rather than end of month, or end of week? Or any other tips for this style of strategy would be greatly appreciated.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.