Home › Forums › Trading System Mentor Course Community › Progress Journal › Hendrik’s Journal
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
September 1, 2021 at 8:52 am #102157HendrikBothaMember
August 2021 – First month (ever) of trading
Performance
US
NDX100 MOMO: +5.8%
MR: -3.5%ASX
WTT: +6.0%Thoughts
I am thrilled with my first month of trading. First, I want to thank Nick, Craig and everyone who share their thoughts, experience and expertise on this forum. It is great to be a member of this community.
Why I started with three strategies and how I chose them
I believe that diversification is the only free lunch in trading, so even though I have a tiny account, I decided to start trading with at least three strategies from the get-go. The three strategies trade different ideas (long term breakout, long term momentum and multi-day mean reversion), and they trade different markets (US and AU) and universes (Russell 1000, NDX100 and ASX All Ordinaries).
I have my MOC Long and MOC Short strategies backtested and ready to go, but I lack the leverage and technology to go live with them at the moment (more on this later).
The ten-year equity curves of the five strategies I want to trade versus an equal weighted portfolio of the 5 strategies are below. The results should be taken with a grain of salt because it assumes equal rebalancing of the five strategies every week. My account size and current technology do not allow me to rebalance weekly, but it is something I will work on in the future. It does, however, clearly show the benefits of diversification. Each of the individual strategies were developed and tested, so they work in their own right. In other words, they have positive expectancy; the only thing left to do is to take as big a bite from that free lunch as I possibly can by diversifying.
The table below shows the annualised volatility, annualised return and sharpe of the strategies and the portfolio
Strategy specific thoughts and observations
ASX All Ords WTT
The strategy has 19 open positions. I am comfortable executing it.NDX100 MOMO
Strategy performed well in August. I am comfortable executing it.Russell 1000 MR
The most annoying thing about this strategy is the commission I have to pay on Interactive Brokers to trade it. I have a small account size, so it really hurts. Paying $1 to buy and then $1 again to sell is not sustainable. 35% of my total loss for this strategy in August was commission paid to Interactive Brokers. Maybe this won’t be such a big problem if there is more volatility in the market? I will probably trade this strategy on IB for another month or two while I build the technology to trade on the commission-free platform Alpaca. Once the technology is developed, I’ll trade this strategy on paper at Alpaca for a month or so in parallel to IB to see what my fills are like and whether Alpaca will be a viable solution. Does anyone in the forum use Alpaca?I’ve seen several trades on this strategy where the trade was profitable at the open at some point and then ultimately sold off and exited at a loss. I wonder if anyone here has tried exiting MR systems at the first open that the trade is profitable. This level of trading would require a step up in technology as I’d need some automated way of exiting if the open is profitable.
Russell 1000 MOC Long
I only paper trade this strategy at the moment.One of the nasty surprises I got was that I couldn’t get 4x Pattern Day Trading leverage at IB because I am an Australian – BUMMER. I found a 0 commission brokerage named Alpaca that (I think) will give me the leverage I require. I’ve developed Python code using their API and have successfully paper traded this strategy for the last week or so. Development is extremely slow because it is a day trading strategy that reveals coding bugs while the US markets are open and I am asleep. Every time I fix a bug, I have to wait 24 hours and sometimes a weekend to see if my bug is fixed. It feels like I’m developing code on a punch card and waiting for the mainframe to spit out the answer like it is 1970 or something. The biggest worry here is whether I will get good fills with this broker when live trading. If this doesn’t work, then I’ll have to try the same approach at Tradestation.
Russell 1000 MOC Short
Similar development stage and problems as MOC Long. I’m somewhat concerned about the fact that Nick has stopped trading this strategy due to backtest results substantially differing from live trading results.That is it for my first month of trading. It was a steep and enjoyable learning curve and I am looking forward to read how everyone else performed this month.
Happy trading everyone!!
September 1, 2021 at 9:01 am #113788Nick RadgeKeymasterWhy not IB Lite? $0 commissions and use the API.
September 1, 2021 at 9:23 am #113791HendrikBothaMemberThanks, Nick, I didn’t know the commission on IB Lite is $0. Definitely looking into IB Lite and the difference between IB Lite and IB Pro tonight.
September 1, 2021 at 12:22 pm #113793HendrikBothaMemberI was unable to switch to IB Lite. Some further research revealed it is only available to those satisfying the below conditions.
Account Types and Clients Eligible for IBKR Lite
US resident individuals, joint, IRA and trust accounts
US Professional or Non-Professional Advisors (Review Requirements) and their clients
US fully disclosed introducing brokers and their clients
*IBKR may allow introducing brokers to go Lite on an exceptional basis.December 1, 2021 at 7:28 am #113795HendrikBothaMemberNovember 2021
US
NDX100 MOMO: -4.5%
MR: +9.6%
MOC LONG: -1.9%ASX
WTT: -4.2%Took me a while to implement the software that executes the MR and MOC strategies on Alpaca. I’ve been running the MR and MOC systems live and automated on Alpaca since mid October.
December 1, 2021 at 12:08 pm #114123RobertMontgomeryParticipantHi Hendrik, Is this the “Alpaca” you are referring to? https://alpaca.markets/
December 1, 2021 at 1:32 pm #114124TimothyStricklandMemberGreat job on the MR system Hendrik, that’s incredible considering a lot of other people’s MRV’s are struggling at the moment.
December 2, 2021 at 6:07 am #114133HendrikBothaMemberThank you Tim.
All that good luck in the MR system got wiped out in a single day on my MOC system yesterday 1 December that lost 8% in a single day!.
December 2, 2021 at 1:18 pm #114142OliverBensonMemberI feel your pain Hendrik!..
January 2, 2022 at 3:52 am #114130HendrikBothaMemberHi Rob sorry I didn’t see the question you posted. Yes, the Alpaca I talk about is alpaca.markets
January 2, 2022 at 4:15 am #113789HendrikBothaMemberDecember 2021
US
NDX100 MOMO: -4.07%
MR: 15.94%
MOC LONG: -2.9%
ASX
WTT: -4.05%
MR system continued to perform well. MOC system somewhat recovered after taking a massive 8% loss in a single day early in December. WTT was out of the market most of December, but back up to 95% invested on Tuesday
February 1, 2022 at 3:32 am #113790HendrikBothaMemberJanuary 2022
US
NDX100 MOMO: -23%
MOC: 14%
MR turned MOC LONG 2: 7.6%ASX
WTT: -6%February 2, 2022 at 1:57 am #114356BenOsbornParticipantHi Hendrik,
I have run into the same problem as you with IB and leverage. I am in the process of developing a MOC system and was considering Tradestation.
I wouldn’t mind having a chat with you about Alpaca, how you have found them, any challenges, how difficult it has been to get the API running, does it do what you want, drawbacks etc (my coding experience is pretty much limited to this program but I am not afraid to give it a go).
If you are happy to message or chat my skype address is benosbornmac or my email address is [email protected].
Nice results on your MOC strategies.
Cheers,
BenFebruary 2, 2022 at 3:05 am #114364HendrikBothaMemberHi Ben,
I’ll be happy to discuss my experience with Alpaca. I initially started down the Tradestation path, but I found the Alpaca API easier to understand and implement.
I’ll add you to Skype and we can have a chat at some point.
Cheers,
HendrikMarch 1, 2022 at 2:37 am #114366HendrikBothaMemberFebruary 2022
US
NDX100: 0%
MOC LONG: 12.35%
MOC LONG 2: 13.88%ASX
WTT: 0.86%
Market On Close strategies both performed well in February while WTT was flat and MOMO strategy remained switched off. WTT is only 30% invested.
Market On Close missed two days of positive returns due to a bug in my code on one day where an untradeable security resulted in none of my orders being placed. I have now fixed that bug. The following day no orders were placed because my trade server went offline. MOC returns would have been higher had these two events not occurred. So happy I didn’t miss the massive return day on 24 February!
I have now had two massive return days (>10%) in the last two months in the MOC strategies. Nobody is going to complain about such days, but it started to make me think about the volatility in these strategies as it might as well have been down days. I did a quick volatility analysis on one of my MOC systems and noticed something quite interesting. Average 60 trading day rolling annualised vol prior to March 2020 hardly ever exceeded 30% and averaged 20% over 10 years. Since March 2020 average vol has doubled to 40% and there have been long periods of trading at 70% vol! I think this is dangerous and I am seriously considering adjusting position size to target a maximum of 30% vol. Especially given that the majority of the backtest period on which basis I am trading had vol of about 20% which seems a lot more reasonable.
I would love to get your thoughts on this.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.